Fight Landlords Blog

What Steps Should Tenants Take When They Receive an Eviction Notice They Consider Illegal?

By FightLandlords
What Steps Should Tenants Take When They Receive an Eviction Notice They Consider Illegal?

When you receive an eviction notice you believe is illegal, the clock starts ticking immediately—and your response in the first 24-72 hours often determines whether you stay in your home or lose it by default. Most tenants lose not because landlords have valid grounds, but because tenants don't know what to do or act too slowly.

Understanding exactly what kind of notice you received and taking the right immediate actions is what separates tenants who successfully fight illegal evictions from those who get displaced despite having strong legal defenses.

Why Speed and Precision Matter

The harsh reality of eviction timelines:

What "illegal" eviction notice means:

The trap tenants fall into: Many tenants think "this notice is illegal, so I don't need to respond." Wrong. You must actively challenge illegal notices through proper legal channels, or courts will process the case and evict you anyway.

Step 1: Identify Exactly What Kind of Notice You Received

Different documents require completely different responses. Misidentifying what you received wastes critical time.

Pre-Court Termination Notices

What these look like:

What they mean:

Critical understanding: In New York, landlords CANNOT evict you with just a letter. Only Housing Court can order eviction, and only a marshal can physically remove you.

What termination notices are:

14-day rent demand (nonpayment cases):

30/60/90-day termination notice (holdover cases):

Notice to cure:

What to look for in termination notices:

Defects that make notice illegal:

Your immediate action:

Important: Even though this isn't court yet, respond immediately because:

Housing Court Papers (Case Has Started)

What these look like:

What they mean:

Critical understanding: This is real court papers. This is serious. You have very short deadline to file written Answer.

Information on court papers:

Notice of Petition shows:

Petition shows:

Service of process requirements:

Defects making court papers illegal:

Service defects:

Content defects:

Your critical deadline:

Your immediate action (within 24-48 hours):

Marshal's Notice of Eviction (Post-Judgment)

What this looks like:

What it means:

How this happens:

Your emergency actions:

If you never knew about court case:

If you lost at trial but judgment is wrong:

If you violated settlement stipulation:

Critical understanding: Marshal's notice means eviction is imminent. This is the last chance. Act within 24 hours or you will be physically removed.

Illegal Lockout (No Court Process)

What this is:

What it means:

This is completely different from above scenarios: You're not defending eviction—you're the victim of crime seeking restoration.

Your immediate actions (same day, within hours):

1. Call 911:

2. Document everything:

3. Go to Housing Court same day or next business day:

Your legal rights:

Step 2: Analyze Whether the Notice/Case Is Illegal

Once you know what type of notice you have, examine it for defects that make it legally insufficient.

Common Illegal Notice Problems

Wrong information:

Procedural defects:

Substantive defects:

Spotting Illegal Court Papers

Service problems:

Petition defects:

Standing issues:

Good Cause Violations (Covered NYC Areas)

If Good Cause applies to your unit:

Notice must state valid grounds:

Invalid grounds include:

Notice must properly claim exemption if applicable:

Defects to look for:

Retaliation Red Flags

Timing that suggests illegal retaliation:

Evidence of retaliation:

Why this makes notice illegal: RPL § 223-b prohibits retaliation, creates presumption of retaliation within one year of protected activity, shifts burden to landlord to prove non-retaliation.

Step 3: Take Immediate Action Based on Notice Type

Your specific response depends on what you received and what's wrong with it.

Response to Termination Notice (Pre-Court)

Step 1: Document receipt (immediately)

Step 2: Calculate deadlines (within 24 hours)

Step 3: Contact legal services (within 48 hours)

Step 4: Prepare defense evidence (immediately)

Step 5: Consider responding in writing Your attorney may advise sending written response to landlord pointing out defects and asserting defenses:

Example response letter: "I received your [14-day notice/termination notice] dated [date]. This notice is defective because [specific reasons]. Additionally, [state defenses like retaliation, discrimination, Good Cause violation]. I am not moving and will assert all defenses if you file in Housing Court."

Why respond:

Step 6: Monitor for court papers

Response to Housing Court Papers

URGENT: You have very limited time

Step 1: Calculate Answer deadline (immediately)

Step 2: Get to legal services (within 24-48 hours)

Step 3: Draft and file Answer (before deadline)

Your Answer must include:

Caption:

General denial:

Affirmative defenses: List every applicable defense:

Counterclaims:

Verification:

Prayer for relief:

Step 4: Serve Answer on landlord's attorney

Step 5: File Answer with court

Step 6: Appear at all court dates

What if deadline is today or tomorrow:

Response to Marshal's Notice

EXTREME EMERGENCY: Act within 24 hours

If you never knew about court case:

Step 1: Same day - go to Housing Court

Step 2: File Order to Show Cause Your papers must include:

Step 3: Request temporary restraining order

Step 4: Serve landlord and marshal

Step 5: Attend hearing

If you lost at trial or violated stipulation:

Options are more limited:

Hardship stay: Even if can't reopen case, can request delay:

Step 6: Pay arrears if possible In nonpayment cases:

Response to Illegal Lockout

IMMEDIATE EMERGENCY: Act within hours

Step 1: Call 911 (immediately)

What to bring for police:

What to tell police:

If police help:

If police won't help:

Step 2: Document lockout (within hours)

Step 3: Go to Housing Court (same day or next business day)

File illegal lockout case:

Your papers must include:

Relief to request:

Step 4: Serve landlord

Step 5: Attend emergency hearing

Step 6: Enforce court order

Step 4: Get Legal Help Immediately

You need professional assistance. Free services are available.

NYC Legal Services

Right to Counsel (income-eligible tenants):

Legal Aid Society:

Legal Services NYC:

Housing Court Answers:

Statewide Resources

LawHelpNY.org:

Local legal aid:

What to Bring to Attorney

Essential documents:

Information to provide:

What Attorney Can Do

Immediate assistance:

Ongoing representation:

Why attorney helps:

Studies show represented tenants are 77% more likely to remain housed than unrepresented tenants.

Step 5: Explore All Options to Resolve

Beyond defending in court, other options may resolve the situation.

Emergency Rental Assistance

If you owe rent:

How to access:

Housing Court Mediation

Settlement conferences:

Typical settlement terms:

Considerations:

Direct Negotiation

Your attorney may negotiate with landlord's attorney:

When negotiation works:

Step 6: Prepare for Court

If case isn't resolved, prepare thoroughly for Housing Court proceedings.

Gathering Evidence

Documents to collect:

Witnesses to prepare:

Understanding Court Process

First appearance:

Discovery:

Trial:

Possible outcomes:

Your Testimony

Prepare to testify:

What judge wants to know:

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Biggest errors tenants make:

1. Ignoring the notice

2. Missing deadlines

3. Not documenting

4. Acting without legal advice

5. Accepting bad settlement

6. Communicating directly with landlord

7. Paying rent to wrong party

8. Not appearing at court dates

Your Response Determines Your Outcome

Receiving an eviction notice you believe is illegal creates a critical decision point. The steps you take in the first hours and days determine whether you successfully challenge the illegal eviction or lose your home by default.

Know what type of notice you received. Identify the specific legal defects. File timely written Answer with all defenses. Get legal help immediately. Document everything. Appear at all court dates. Assert every available defense vigorously.

Illegal eviction notices are common. Landlords routinely fail to follow required procedures, claim invalid grounds, retaliate against complaints, and bypass legal requirements. But these violations only protect you if you actively challenge them through proper legal channels.

The law provides defenses against illegal evictions—but only for tenants who assert them promptly and properly. Don't let an illegal notice become a legal eviction through your inaction.

Find out if you have a case in 30 seconds →